Matter vs cloud: which smart home connection should you use?

Automation is a key part of any smart home, having things happen automatically, such as lights turning on when the front door is opened, or a presence sensor turning off the heating when nobody is in the room.

Any kind of automation requires devices to be connected in one ecosystem, whether that’s Alexa, Google Home, Homey or Apple Home. Increasingly, there’s a move to use Matter devices, which connect and are controlled directly and locally, although many devices still offer a cloud-based connection via the internet. So, which method is better? Well, it depends on what you want to achieve.

If you’re shopping for new kit, our guide to the best Matter smart home devices is a good place to start.

What is a Matter connection?

Matter is a shared smart home standard backed by Apple, Google, Amazon, Samsung and hundreds of device makers. A Matter device talks directly to a controller on your home network, such as a smart speaker, smart display, Apple TV or hub, over Wi-Fi, Ethernet or Thread. Matter devices can also be connected via a bridge. For example, if you add a Philips Hue Bridge to a Matter system, all of the lights and controllers become available.

The benefits of Matter are many. First, control is direct and in your home. If the internet goes down, Matter devices can keep working, along with any automations you’ve got.

Secondly, that direct connection means faster response times, as control requests don’t have to go to the internet and back.

The main limitation is that Matter devices work to a prescribed device type, which controls which features are available. For example, a light bulb will support on/off, brightness, colour and temperature controls, but manufacturer-specific scenes are not available.

Another limitation is that adding Matter devices can be slow. Take a Tado X system, for example. Each radiator valve has to be added individually; with Tado V3, you could just connect to the cloud to get the entire system.

Similarly to my light bulb example, with Tado X, Matter control lets me turn a device on or off, and set the target temperature. I can’t access the system’s Boost function or turn the entire heating system to off. Tado V3’s cloud connection provides more features.

What is a cloud connection?

With a cloud connection, the device connects to the manufacturer’s servers, and your smart home platform talks to those servers. When you ask Alexa to turn on a light, the request goes from Amazon’s servers to the manufacturer’s servers, then back down to the light in your home.

This is how most smart home devices have worked for years. It gives you full access to every feature in the manufacturer’s app, remote control without a home hub and support for a huge range of products.

The downside is that everything depends on the internet and on the manufacturer. Commands take longer, automations stop if your broadband or the manufacturer’s servers go down, and a device can lose features or stop working if the company changes its service, adds a subscription or shuts down.

Matter vs cloud: comparison

Matter Cloud
How it works Devices talk directly to your controller over your home network (Wi-Fi, Thread or Ethernet) Commands go via the manufacturer’s servers over the internet, often through an Alexa skill or Google Home integration
Internet needed? No for local control. Automations keep running if your broadband drops (hub dependent) Yes. If the internet or the manufacturer’s servers go down, control and automations stop
Speed Fast and consistent, as commands stay on your network Slower and less predictable, as every command makes a round trip to a server
Compatibility One device works with Apple Home, Google Home, Amazon Alexa, SmartThings and Home Assistant Depends on which platforms the manufacturer supports, with a separate skill or integration for each
Multiple platforms at once Yes, through multi-admin (for example Apple Home and Alexa together) Possible, but each link is a separate cloud integration
Hub required A Matter controller, such as a smart speaker, smart display, Apple TV or hub. Thread devices also need a Thread border router Usually not, just the manufacturer’s app (some brands use their own bridge)
Features Only what Matter supports for that device type, so advanced features often still need the manufacturer’s app Full access to every feature in the manufacturer’s app
Remote access Through your platform’s home hub Built into the manufacturer’s app
Setup Scan a QR code or enter a pairing code in any Matter app Create an account in the manufacturer’s app, then link it to each platform
Privacy Control stays on your home network Usage data passes through the manufacturer’s servers
Long-term risk Low. Devices keep working locally if the manufacturer drops support Higher. Devices can stop working if the service closes, its integration changes or a subscription is added
Device choice Growing, but some categories and features are limited or missing Very wide, including older and niche products
Best for Reliability, mixing ecosystems and future-proofing Getting every feature, or devices without Matter support

Which should you choose?

Choose Matter if you want:

  • Fast, reliable control that works without the internet
  • Freedom to use more than one smart home platform
  • Devices that keep working if the manufacturer drops support
  • Automations that run locally, such as lights triggered by sensors

A cloud connection makes sense if you want:

  • Every feature the device offers, without opening another app
  • A device that doesn’t yet support Matter
  • Remote access without buying a home hub

In short, Matter is the better choice for everyday control, while the cloud is better for getting the most out of a device.

Using both

You don’t always have to choose. Many devices now support Matter alongside their own app, so you can use Matter for fast, local control and automations, and keep the manufacturer’s app for advanced settings and firmware updates. Platforms are also moving more devices to local Matter control. For example, Philips Hue lights now get local Matter control in Google Home.

FAQs

Do Matter devices work without the internet?

Yes, for control and automations within your home. You’ll still need the internet for remote access, voice assistants that process speech in the cloud, and firmware updates.

Do I need a hub for Matter?

You need a Matter controller, but you may already have one. Many recent smart speakers, smart displays and streaming boxes act as controllers. Thread devices also need a Thread border router, which is built into many of the same products.

Can a device use Matter and the cloud at the same time?

Yes. Many devices let you add them to a platform through Matter while still using the manufacturer’s app. Just avoid adding the same device to one platform through both Matter and a cloud integration, or you’ll end up with duplicates.

Is Matter more secure than the cloud?

Matter uses encryption and device certification, and keeping control on your home network reduces how much data leaves your home. Cloud services can also be secure, but they add another company’s servers that your data has to pass through.

Minha Loja Teresa
We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

My Teresa Store
Logo
Shopping cart